Alpha vs beta binaural beats for studying: what is known
By Luis6 min read
Nobody has shown that alpha or beta binaural beats are better for studying, and the idea behind both is uncertain. Alpha (8 to 14 hertz) is the brain rhythm linked with being awake and relaxed; beta (14 to 30 hertz) is linked with alert, active thinking. The claim is that a beat at one of those frequencies pushes your brain into that rhythm, but a 2023 review of 14 EEG studies found 5 that supported it, 8 that did not and 1 mixed. If you want to try them, alpha for calm reading and beta for dull work where you get drowsy are reasonable guesses, not findings. Use headphones, keep them quiet, and test for a week.
What a binaural beat is
Play a 200 hertz tone in one ear and a 210 hertz tone in the other, and you hear a slow pulse at 10 hertz, the difference between them. The pulse is not in the air; the brain creates it by comparing the two ears. That is why headphones are required: through speakers, both tones reach both ears and the beat disappears. There is a longer explanation in do binaural beats work?
Alpha and beta, in plain terms
Brain activity measured with EEG shows rhythms at different speeds, grouped into bands. Hans Berger, who recorded the first human EEG, noticed in 1929 that a rhythm around 10 hertz was strongest when people rested with their eyes closed and faded when they opened their eyes or concentrated. That is the alpha rhythm. Faster, lower-amplitude beta activity is more prominent when people are awake, alert and thinking actively.
These describe what the brain does in different states. They do not show that playing a sound at a frequency puts you in that state. That second step is the claim binaural beats make, and it is the weak link.
| Band | Kiri's range | Usually linked with |
|---|---|---|
| Delta | 1 to 4 Hz | Deep sleep |
| Theta | 4 to 8 Hz | Drowsiness and light sleep; also seen in some memory tasks and meditation |
| Alpha | 8 to 14 Hz | Awake and relaxed, strongest with the eyes closed |
| Beta | 14 to 30 Hz | Awake, alert, actively thinking |
| Gamma | 30 to 100 Hz | Fast activity linked in research with attention and memory; hard to record cleanly |
Band edges differ slightly between textbooks; the ranges above are the ones Kiri uses.
Sources: Berger (1929), "Über das Elektrenkephalogramm des Menschen", Archiv für Psychiatrie und Nervenkrankheiten, 87.What the evidence says
On whether beats change behaviour. Garcia-Argibay, Santed and Reales (2019) pooled 22 studies, 35 effect sizes in all, on memory, attention, anxiety and pain. They reported an overall positive effect they described as medium (g = 0.45), larger when people listened before the task rather than only during it. The studies used different frequencies, tasks and listening times, so the average says little about any one band or any one person.
On whether the brain follows the beat. Ingendoh, Posny and Heine (2023) reviewed 14 studies that measured brain activity with EEG during binaural beats. Five found results in line with entrainment, the idea that the brain falls into step with the beat; eight found results that contradicted it; one was mixed. The authors noted that the studies differed so much in method that firm conclusions are not yet possible.
On beta specifically. Lane and colleagues (1998) compared beta beats with theta and delta beats during a dull vigilance task, without telling people whether beats were present. With beta beats, people caught more targets, made fewer false alarms and reported less negative mood. It compared beta with slow beats, not with alpha or silence, and it measured performance, not brain activity.
Sources: Garcia-Argibay, Santed & Reales (2019), "Efficacy of binaural auditory beats in cognition, anxiety, and pain perception: a meta-analysis", Psychological Research, 83(2). Ingendoh, Posny & Heine (2023), "Binaural beats to entrain the brain? A systematic review of the effects of binaural beat stimulation on brain oscillatory activity, and the implications for psychological research and intervention", PLOS ONE, 18(5). Lane, Kasian, Owens & Marsh (1998), "Binaural auditory beats affect vigilance performance and mood", Physiology & Behavior, 63(2).So, alpha or beta?
What is known: across studies, binaural beats show a positive average effect on some tasks, the studies differ a lot in method, and the brainwave mechanism is not well supported. What is not known: whether alpha or beta is better for studying. We could not find a study that compared the two on studying itself.
If you want a starting point, use the bands as hypotheses that match how each rhythm is described:
- Alpha for reading and revision when you feel tense or restless and want to settle.
- Beta for dull, repetitive work, such as flashcards or checking, when you tend to get drowsy. This is the closest match to the 1998 vigilance study.
- Neither if pure tones irritate you. Steady sound such as rain or brown noise has a better-established benefit, which is covering voices in the room.
Whichever you use, keep the beats quiet, under a soundscape rather than on their own; pure tones on their own get tiring. If you are choosing the sound underneath, brown noise vs white noise for studying covers that.
A one-week self-test
- Pick one kind of work and one block length for the whole week, such as a 25-minute or 50-minute timer. Same soundscape, same headphones, same volume.
- Rotate the beats by day: alpha on days one and four, beta on days two and five, no beats on days three and six.
- After each block, before the break, write two things: a score from one to five for how easily you stayed on task, and how much you got through, in pages, problems or cards.
- On day seven, compare the averages. If one setting is clearly ahead on both numbers, keep it. If you cannot tell them apart, turn the beats off; you have lost nothing.
It is not a controlled trial, and knowing which setting is on will colour your scores. It is still better evidence about you than any article. In Kiri, the timer on this page, all the beats come with the full version, €39 once at the founding price, with a 30-day refund; a new account gets 14 days of every beat, which is long enough to run the test.
Questions
Are alpha or beta binaural beats better for studying?
Nobody knows. We could not find a study comparing the two on studying, and reviews find the brainwave effect behind both is uncertain. Alpha for calm reading and beta for dull work where you get drowsy are reasonable guesses to test, not findings.
Do binaural beats actually change your brainwaves?
The evidence is mixed. A 2023 systematic review of 14 EEG studies found 5 that supported entrainment, 8 that contradicted it and 1 with mixed results, and the studies differed a lot in method.
Do I need headphones for binaural beats?
Yes. Each ear has to hear a different tone. Through speakers, both tones reach both ears and the beat is lost.
What frequency is alpha and what is beta?
In Kiri, alpha is 8 to 14 hertz and beta is 14 to 30 hertz. Textbooks draw the edges slightly differently, but alpha is around 10 hertz and beta is faster.
How long should I listen before it works?
A 2019 meta-analysis found larger effects when people listened before the task rather than only during it, but there is no agreed time. Start the beats a few minutes before you begin and judge them over a week, not a single session.