Lofi or brown noise for studying: what the research shows
By Luis6 min read
For reading, writing and memorising, brown noise or another steady sound is the safer choice than lofi, because it has no words and no melody to follow. Instrumental lofi may be fine for many people, and lofi with vocal samples is the kind to avoid. But no study we could find has compared lofi with brown noise, so this is reasoning from nearby research and not a tested result. If the problem is voices in the room, pink noise or rain covers them more fully than brown noise does.
This article is written by Luis, who makes Kiri, the timer on this page. Kiri plays brown noise and has no lofi, so keep that in mind as you read.
What has been tested: words and music
Overheard speech. Salamé and Baddeley (1982) showed that speech people were told to ignore still disrupted short-term memory. This is the irrelevant speech effect, and it has been replicated many times. Reading, writing and memorising all lean on the same part of memory.
Music against noise. In a later study, Salamé and Baddeley (1989) compared several kinds of background sound on short-term memory. Noise was no more disruptive than silence. Instrumental music was more disruptive than both, and speech was the most disruptive. That is the closest thing to a direct argument for noise over instrumental music, but it was a memory task in a lab, and it did not use lofi or brown noise.
Lyrics and reading. Perham and Currie (2014) tested reading comprehension with liked music, disliked music, instrumental music and silence. Music with lyrics hurt more than instrumental music or silence, whether or not people liked it. Liking your playlist did not protect you. Vasilev, Hitching and Tyrrell (2023) also found lyrical music distracting during reading, and instrumental music not.
Music in general. A 2011 review by Kämpfe, Sedlmeier and Renkewitz found that the average effect of background music was close to zero, because small helps and small harms cancelled out across people and tasks.
Sources: Salamé & Baddeley (1982), Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 21(2). Salamé & Baddeley (1989), "Effects of background music on phonological short-term memory", Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology, 41A(1). Perham & Currie (2014), Applied Cognitive Psychology, 28(2). Vasilev, Hitching & Tyrrell (2023), Journal of Cognitive Psychology. Kämpfe, Sedlmeier & Renkewitz (2011), Psychology of Music, 39(4).What is untested for lofi
Almost everything. The clearest study we found is a pilot by Flores (2021) in a student psychology journal. It compared lofi (32 people), classical music (22) and no music (32) on spatial and reading comprehension tests, and found no differences between the groups. So lofi neither helped nor hurt there. It is one small study, and a null result from a small sample cannot show that lofi has no effect.
We also found a short paper from an Indonesian university journal reporting better attention with lofi. We could not read its methods, so we give it little weight. We found no large or replicated experiment on lofi and studying.
"Lofi" is also not one sound. Tempo, melody and samples vary from track to track, and some tracks carry snippets of voices. Those snippets may behave like lyrics or speech, but that is our inference. Nobody appears to have tested it. Nor do we know whether a long playlist, where the tracks keep changing, differs from a single looped piece.
Sources: Flores (2021), "The Effects of Music Genre on Scores in Different Exam Types: A Pilot Study", Kwantlen Psychology Student Journal, issue 3. Universitas Mercu Buana paper, read only in summary.What is untested for brown noise
Brown noise is no better documented. When Nigg and colleagues (2024) reviewed noise and attention in people with ADHD, they found no brown noise studies that met their criteria. The ones they could pool used white or pink noise. The 1989 finding that noise was no worse than silence does not tell us that brown noise helps you study.
The case for brown noise rests on what it does not contain, and on comfort. It has no words, no tune and no events. Many people find its low rumble easy to leave on for an hour. There is more in brown noise vs white noise for studying.
It also has a weakness. Brown noise puts most of its energy low, and the parts of speech that carry words sit in the middle and upper frequencies. So it softens voices, but pink noise or rain covers them more fully at the same volume. If you can still follow what your flatmate is saying, brown noise is the wrong tool, however pleasant it is. Small laptop speakers also lose much of it.
Sources: Nigg et al. (2024), Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 63(8).How to choose
- Reading, writing, memorising in a quiet room: brown noise at low volume, or silence. Avoid anything with words.
- The same work with people talking nearby: pink noise or rain, just loud enough that you cannot follow the words.
- Problem sets, coding, drawing, tidying notes: instrumental lofi is a reasonable choice, especially if it helps you start or keeps your mood up. Language is less involved in this kind of work, though that is a judgement more than a tested rule for lofi.
- You find noise boring within minutes: instrumental lofi you already know. A sound you will actually keep on beats a better one you switch off.
- Any task: pick playlists without vocal samples, and avoid videos with a live chat beside them.
Settle it in a week
Pick one kind of work and one block length, such as a 25-minute timer. Alternate lofi and brown noise by day, and keep the volume the same. After each block, write down how far you got and how often you noticed the sound. You will know which day was which, so your scores will be biased, but it is still better evidence about you than a study of someone else.
Where Kiri fits, and who should not use it
Kiri is a Pomodoro and focus timer with ten ambient sounds on a laptop or desktop. Brown, pink and white noise are not recordings; rain and the other nature and café sounds are built from real field recordings. The timer, rain and brown noise are free. Pink noise, the binaural beats and the rest are €39 once at the Founding price, €49 after 500 licences, with a 30-day refund. Kiri has no ratings yet and very few users, and nobody independent has tested its sound.
Kiri is the wrong choice if you want music. It has none. Keep your lofi playlist, and if you still want a timer, turn Kiri's sound off and run the block with your music in another tab. It is also wrong if you want sound on your phone, or if you need site blocking or a native Mac app. If you want music made for focus, read our Brain.fm comparison.
Questions
Is lofi or brown noise better for studying?
No study we could find has compared them. For reading and memorising, brown noise is the safer choice because it has no words or melody. Instrumental lofi may suit problem sets and other work that uses less language.
Does lofi music help you study?
There is very little evidence either way. The clearest study we found, a small student pilot from 2021, found no difference between lofi, classical music and silence on spatial and reading tests.
Is music with lyrics bad for studying?
For reading, it tends to be. In Perham and Currie (2014), music with lyrics hurt reading comprehension more than instrumental music or silence, whether people liked the music or not.
Does brown noise block out voices?
Only partly. Its energy sits low, and words sit in the middle and upper frequencies, so it softens voices without hiding them. Pink noise or rain covers voices more fully at the same volume.
Is brown noise proven to help you focus?
No. A 2024 meta-analysis of noise and attention found no brown noise studies that met its criteria. People use it because it is comfortable and contains nothing to follow.
Does Kiri have lofi?
No. Kiri has ambient sounds, noise and binaural beats, and no music. You can turn its sound off and play your own lofi alongside the timer.