A Coffitivity alternative: café sounds for studying
By Luis5 min read
If you are looking for a Coffitivity alternative, the sound itself is easy to find: Noisli, long café recordings on YouTube and Kiri, the timer on this page, all play café ambience. The more useful question is when café sound helps. The best-known study found that a moderate level of café-style noise, around 70 decibels, improved performance on creative tasks, while a louder level hurt. That was creativity, not memorising. For reading and revision, especially if you can make out words in the recording, plainer sound such as rain or brown noise is the safer choice.
What Coffitivity is
Coffitivity is a café-sound site and app that has been around since the early 2010s. It plays recorded coffee-shop ambience, meant to run quietly under your work or alongside your own music. We could not confirm its current prices or which of its versions are still updated, so check its own site before deciding.
What the research on café noise found
Mehta, Zhu and Cheema (2012) ran five experiments on ambient noise and creative thinking. They played recorded background noise at a low level of 50 decibels, a moderate level of 70 and a high level of 85. At 70 decibels, people did better on creative tasks, such as finding a word that links three others and coming up with new ideas, than at 50. At 85 decibels they did worse.
The authors' explanation is that a moderate amount of noise makes thinking slightly harder, which nudges people to think more abstractly, and abstract thinking helps creative work. Too much noise makes it hard to think at all. Two limits matter. The study measured creative tasks, not memorising, reading comprehension or exam revision. And it is one paper, often quoted far beyond what it tested.
Sources: Mehta, Zhu & Cheema (2012), "Is Noise Always Bad? Exploring the Effects of Ambient Noise on Creative Cognition", Journal of Consumer Research, 39(4).When café sound works against you
The risk in a café recording is speech. Overheard talking, even in a language you do not know, reliably lowers performance on tasks that lean on working memory; this is the irrelevant speech effect, first shown by Salamé and Baddeley (1982) and replicated many times since. Reading, writing and memorising all use that channel. A murmur you cannot follow is mostly texture; a voice you can understand competes with the words on the page.
Lyrics do the same. Perham and Currie (2014) found students scored lower on reading comprehension with music with lyrics playing than in silence, and the music they liked was no better than music they did not. So if your café recording has a clear conversation at the next table, or you play it with a playlist that has singing, it is working against reading-heavy study.
Sources: Salamé & Baddeley (1982), "Disruption of short-term memory by unattended speech: Implications for the structure of working memory", Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior, 21(2). Perham & Currie (2014), "Does listening to preferred music improve reading comprehension performance?", Applied Cognitive Psychology, 28(2).When to use café sound, and when not
- Brainstorming, planning, essay outlines, design work: café sound is a reasonable choice. This is the kind of task the 2012 study tested.
- Reading, memorising, writing a careful paragraph: rain or brown noise, or silence if the room allows it. No voices, nothing to follow.
- Problem sets and coding: either can work. Try café sound for a week and switch if you catch yourself listening to it.
- A noisy flat or open office: steady sound covers voices better than a recording that has voices in it. Pink noise or brown noise first.
- Working alone and it feels too quiet: café sound makes a room feel occupied for many people. That is a feeling, not a measured effect, but it is a fair reason to use it. If it is company you miss rather than noise, Focusmate alternatives covers coworking on video, free and paid.
On volume: the helpful level in the study was moderate and the loud one hurt. At a desk with headphones, start lower than you think and turn it up only until the room disappears. For more on what helps which task, read ambient sounds for studying.
Coffitivity alternatives at a glance
- Noisli. A mixer with a coffee shop sound among rain, wind and others. A free plan with a daily limit and a Pro subscription; see our Noisli comparison for prices.
- Long café recordings on YouTube. Free and plentiful. The catch is what sits next to them: recommendations, comments and autoplay. And some have clear conversations in them.
- A real café or a library. Free with a coffee. Real speech is easier to follow than a recording, so it suits planning more than revision.
- Kiri. A focus timer with ambient sound in the same tab, on a laptop or desktop only. The café soundscape is blended from long real field recordings, and it is part of the full version, with forest, fireplace, sea, wind, waterfall, pink and white noise. The timer, rain and brown noise are free. The full set is €39 once, at the founding price, with a 30-day refund.
When Coffitivity may still suit you better
- You only want café sound under your own music. That is what Coffitivity was built for. Kiri plays one soundscape at a time; you can still play music in another tab.
- You want café sound on your phone. Kiri has no phone app, on purpose, so the phone can go in another room.
- You do not want a timer. Kiri is built around timed blocks. If you just want sound, a sound app is simpler.
Test it on your own work
For a week, alternate café sound and rain on the same kind of task, in the same length of block, such as a 25-minute timer. After each block, note how far you got and whether you caught yourself listening. Café sound that helps an outline may hurt a chapter of reading, and your own numbers will tell you more than a study can.
Questions
Are café sounds good for studying?
For creative work such as planning and brainstorming, possibly: a 2012 study found moderate café-style noise helped creative tasks. For reading and memorising, voices you can understand tend to hurt, so rain or brown noise is the safer choice.
How loud should café sounds be?
Moderate. In the 2012 study the helpful level was around 70 decibels and 85 decibels hurt. At a desk with headphones, set it just loud enough to cover the room and no louder.
Does café noise help you memorise?
There is no good evidence that it does. The study usually quoted tested creativity, not memory, and overheard speech is known to disrupt memory tasks. Use steady sound without voices for memorising.
What is a good Coffitivity alternative?
Noisli has a coffee shop sound in its mixer, YouTube has long café recordings for free, and Kiri pairs a café soundscape from real field recordings with a focus timer on the laptop. We could not confirm Coffitivity's current prices, so check its site.
Is Kiri's café sound free?
No. The café soundscape is part of the full version, €39 once with a 30-day refund. The timer, rain and brown noise are free.