Brown noise vs white noise for studying: which is better?

By LuisUpdated 6 min read

Neither has been shown to be better for studying: no published study has compared brown noise and white noise head to head on learning. White noise is the one with research behind it, and the results are mixed; brown noise has almost none, so the honest way to choose is by comfort and by what you need to cover. For most people studying for an hour in a noisy place, brown noise at low volume is the easier of the two to live with, and white noise is worth a try if you are memorising.

The difference in one paragraph

White noise has equal energy at every frequency, so it sounds like a hard hiss. Brown noise (also called Brownian or red noise, after Brownian motion, not the colour) loses energy as the pitch rises, so it sounds like a low rumble: a plane cabin, a river through a wall. Pink noise sits in between and sounds like steady rain. There is a longer explanation of all three in brown, white or pink noise: which is best for focus.

What the studies on white noise and learning found

A handful of lab studies have tested white noise while people learn or remember things. They do not agree, which is the most useful thing to know about them.

  • Word learning went up. In Angwin and colleagues (2017), 80 adults learned made-up names for twenty objects, half in silence and half with white noise. The noise group recalled the names more accurately across the training. It is one study, with one kind of material.
  • Working memory went down. Herweg and Bunzeck (2015) ran five experiments with 167 adults. White noise played while people held items in working memory lowered accuracy. The authors concluded white noise has no general effect on thinking; it depends on the task and on when the noise is playing.
  • Volume mattered. Awada and colleagues (2022) tested about forty graduate students. White noise at 45 decibels, quieter than a normal conversation, went with better sustained attention and less stress than silence. At 65 decibels working memory improved but stress went up.
  • ADHD is a special case. A 2024 meta-analysis by Nigg and colleagues pooled 13 studies with 335 participants and found a small benefit from white or pink noise on attention tasks for people with ADHD or high ADHD symptoms, and no benefit for everyone else. Earlier work by Söderlund and colleagues (2010) found the same split in schoolchildren: inattentive pupils remembered more with noise, attentive pupils remembered less.
Sources: Angwin et al. (2017), Scientific Reports, 7:13045. Herweg & Bunzeck (2015), Frontiers in Psychology, 6:1639. Awada et al. (2022), Scientific Reports, 12. Nigg et al. (2024), Journal of the American Academy of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, 63(8). Söderlund, Sikström, Loftesnes & Sonuga-Barke (2010), Behavioral and Brain Functions, 6:55.

What the studies on brown noise found

Very little. When Nigg and colleagues searched the literature for their 2024 review, they found no brown noise studies that met their criteria, despite its popularity. The wave of interest since 2022 came from social media, not from labs. That does not mean brown noise does nothing; it means nobody has measured it properly yet.

What we can say comes from the sound itself. Brown noise puts most of its energy low, so it covers traffic, a washing machine and the low half of voices without the hiss that makes white noise tiring after twenty minutes. The cost is that it covers high-pitched sounds less well, and on small laptop speakers much of it simply disappears.

How to choose for a study session

  • A quiet room you want to fill: brown noise, low. It is the least fatiguing for long sessions.
  • Housemates talking, a busy library: brown or pink noise, just loud enough that you can no longer follow the words. Following speech is what hurts reading and memorising.
  • High-pitched sounds, like a fan whine or a buzzing light: white noise or pink, which have more energy up there.
  • Memorising vocabulary or terms: white noise is the one with a positive study, so it is worth a week's trial.
  • Laptop speakers, no headphones: pink noise or rain. Brown noise turns to mud on small speakers.

Whichever colour you pick, keep it low. The better result in Awada's study came at 45 decibels. If you can feel the noise, it is too loud; if you stop noticing it after a minute, it is right.

Settle it in a week

Alternate: brown noise one day, white the next, same kind of work, same length of block, such as a 25-minute timer. Write down how many pages or problems you got through. After a week the numbers usually answer the question better than any article. In Kiri, the player above, brown noise and rain are free; white and pink noise come with the full version.

Questions

Is brownian noise the same as brown noise?

Yes. Brown, Brownian and red noise are names for the same sound. It is named after Brownian motion, the random movement of particles, not after the colour.

Is brown noise better than white noise for ADHD?

Nobody knows yet. The ADHD studies used white or pink noise and found a small benefit; a 2024 meta-analysis found no qualifying studies of brown noise. Try both and keep the one that helps.

Can white noise make studying worse?

It can. In some lab studies white noise lowered working memory accuracy, and people without attention problems sometimes did slightly worse with it. If you notice you are re-reading more, switch it off.

How loud should noise be for studying?

Quieter than a normal conversation. One study found better attention at 45 decibels than at 65. Set it just loud enough to cover the room and no louder.